Catallaxy Files

Australia's leading libertarian and centre-right blog

John McTernan: taking Julia Gillard down

106 comments

Those in Labor seem to treat Gillard’s spin merchant, John McTernan, with awe and reverence. He is supposed to be the brains behind Gillard, and is responsible for the present attacks seeking to brand Abbott as a misogynist.

I think she has chosen badly – McTernan’s tactics have always failed. Rather than helping his master stay in a job, McTernan has ensured the master’s removal.

From a range of relatively junior positions, McTernan became Tony Blair’s spin merchant in late 2005. By June 2007 Gordon Brown had unseated the Prime Minister.

Then he helped take out his next master, Des Browne, Secretary of State for Scotland in 2008.

Then he saw off Jim Murphy, the next Secretary of State for Scotland in 2010.

He took up his present role in Gillard’s office just over a year ago (September 2011), and it is only a matter of time before McTernan takes her out too.

McTernan’s true genius is making people think he is helping while quietly undermining them.

Written by Samuel J

October 13th, 2012 at 6:21 pm

Posted in Uncategorized

106 Responses to 'John McTernan: taking Julia Gillard down'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'John McTernan: taking Julia Gillard down'.

  1. So much for the politics of personal destruction.

    dd

    13 Oct 12 at 6:44 pm

  2. But how much of Gillard’s strategy is being driven by McTernan, really? The negative campaign against Abbott has been going since long before he showed up, and in fact Bolt started mocking the “AbbottAbbottAbbott” scare campaign months ago. Are we letting Gillard off the hook by blaming her negative campaign on some faceless guy?

    dd

    13 Oct 12 at 6:46 pm

  3. McTernan became Tony Blair’s spin merchant in late 2005. By June 2007 Gordon Brown had unseated the Prime Minister.

    Then he helped take out his next master, Des Browne, Secretary of State for Scotland in 2008.

    Then he saw off Jim Murphy, the next Secretary of State for Scotland in 2010.

    So what you’re really saying, Samuel is you think it raises the question about the role that Tony Abbott’s playing. :)

    Gab

    13 Oct 12 at 6:51 pm

  4. McTernan’s true genius is making people think he is helping while quietly undermining them.

    And I think it raises the question about the role that Tony Abbott’s playing.

    jupes

    13 Oct 12 at 6:52 pm

  5. why does labor keep talking about abbott? most good governments ignore their opposition. to do otherwise raises their profile to their own.

    any case for reelection must be better that I am not the other guy. a vision?

    It is the right-wing parties who argue they should be re-elected until the Labor party becomes sane again.

    Jim Rose

    13 Oct 12 at 6:52 pm

  6. Gab. Too quick.

    jupes

    13 Oct 12 at 6:53 pm

  7. Jonno better have some distraction aces, Julia claims to have witnessed a signature in Perth she can easily be proved not to have witnessed. That’s a crime.

    Alfonso

    13 Oct 12 at 6:55 pm

  8. Is his salary taxpayer-funded? If so, I’m happy to keep paying him right up till the election…

    ar

    13 Oct 12 at 6:56 pm

  9. :)

    Gab

    13 Oct 12 at 6:57 pm

  10. Jim Rose

    13 Oct 12 at 6:58 pm

  11. PJ, his sexual orientation and his looks are both irrelevant.

    dd

    13 Oct 12 at 6:59 pm

  12. The Cultural Cringe lives on in the PM’s Office. He’s from the Old Dart- he must be the bee’s knees!

    Cold-Hands

    13 Oct 12 at 7:03 pm

  13. Since being here, PJ has commented solely on McTernan’s sexual orientation. One wonders, did PJ get a knockback?

    Gab

    13 Oct 12 at 7:03 pm

  14. I want to know how he is working in Australia. Is he on a work visa, or has someone got him permenant residency? Either way, how does he comply with the “of good character” requirement

    Wilma Karstaardt

    13 Oct 12 at 7:03 pm

  15. John McTernan at http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/jun/24/julia-gillard-can-turn-things-around

    “Ultimately, though, (Rudd) lost his way over climate change. He called it the “greatest moral challenge of our time”, but when facing parliamentary defeat deferred his legislation. His thoughtfulness became his undoing.

    A more populist leader would never have embarked on an emissions trading scheme in advance of other countries, a more Machiavellian one would have manoeuvred his legislation to defeat in the Senate at the joint hands of the Greens and the Liberals.

    Kevin Rudd chose to delay. That caused a catastrophic rupture with voters. Young urban voters split to the Greens and middle Australians to the Liberals.”

    Jim Rose

    13 Oct 12 at 7:04 pm

  16. I think people are forgetting what hopeless political judgment Gillard has demonstrated – virtually since she stood alongside another highly defecient Labor leader in Mark Latham to announce Medicare Gold. Of the policies that supposedly brought down Rudd – Gillard was the author of the boat people policy (admittedly with Rudd’s blessing) and Swan sold him down the creek with his hopeless policy development and implementation of the Resource Super Profit Tax.

    Throw in the backflip on the carbon tax, double-crossing Wilkie on pokies, Craig Thomson affair, appointing Slipper, failing to sack Slipper and the other near weekly stuff-ups that characterise the Gillard government and it is only the political self-interest of the so-called Independents that has kept this farce on its inevitable course with the electoral iceberg.

    As with the Bligh and Keneally governments, a majority of people have been waiting to throw them out from the first day of their formation.

    H B Bear

    13 Oct 12 at 7:11 pm

  17. Since being here, PJ has commented solely on McTernan’s sexual orientation. One wonders, did PJ get a knockback?

    I’d say so. and hence the sour grapes about McTernan’s looks.
    “I wasn’t interested anyway!”

    dd

    13 Oct 12 at 7:21 pm

  18. I had a comment in a different thread, but it took all day to be moderated, so few would have read it. I’ve decided to comment in future using my real name instead of my pseudonym “Hammygar”.

    Gareth Hamilton

    13 Oct 12 at 7:23 pm

  19. No it’s not. It’s Kero Boy and always will be.

    Why do you think anyone gives a shit what your real or new made up name is. Just stay with the old one as it’s better known.

    JC

    13 Oct 12 at 7:27 pm

  20. I’ve decided to comment in future using my real name instead of my pseudonym “Hammygar”.

    Good for you. It wasn’t necessary, and possibly inadvisable, but I admire you for ‘coming out’ nonetheless.

    dd

    13 Oct 12 at 7:29 pm

  21. okay, looks like JC has a different opinion.

    dd

    13 Oct 12 at 7:31 pm

  22. okay, looks like JC has a different opinion.

    Lol.

    Lets not hate each (in Birdian terms) for having different opinions DD.

    JC

    13 Oct 12 at 7:34 pm

  23. I finally get it, (is the comma in the right place??) McTernan is a Liberal Party mole. Now I feel better.

    delfino

    13 Oct 12 at 7:34 pm

  24. Shhhh!

    He’s actually a henchman from the VRWC.

    And he’s henching quite well!

    Mk50 of Brisbane

    13 Oct 12 at 7:37 pm

  25. HenchPERSON Mk50.

    wreckage

    13 Oct 12 at 7:42 pm

  26. This may sound stupid, but how do people know that McTernan is behind the recent Slapper’s fuck ups.

    How you know this? After all she’s quite capable of fucking up all by herself.

    JC

    13 Oct 12 at 7:45 pm

  27. PJ, his sexual orientation and his looks are both irrelevant.

    Not completely. For example, if he was straight and married with kids…

    Fleeced

    13 Oct 12 at 7:51 pm

  28. I wish The Welsh Git would just fuck off Joe

    Tal

    13 Oct 12 at 7:51 pm

  29. Tal

    That of course is a given :-)

    JC

    13 Oct 12 at 7:55 pm

  30. This may sound stupid, but how do people know that McTernan is behind the recent Slapper’s fuck ups.

    How you know this? After all she’s quite capable of fucking up all by herself.

    I agree, and furthermore the buck stops with Gillard.

    dd

    13 Oct 12 at 7:57 pm

  31. I’m swearing and thinking about murdering people,I think I’ll go to confession tomorrow

    Tal

    13 Oct 12 at 7:59 pm

  32. So the Hamster wants to attach years of mad blog commentary to a new identity that makes him unemployable everywhere except the SPA and the CPA? Give us a spell, Hammy. You’re not going to suddenly stop lying about stuff after a lifetime of pretending you are what you aren’t and you aren’t what you are. You won’t be able to pull this off. Just keep lying and calling yourself the Hamster. It’s be easier that way. And if you ever need to earn a living outside the Australian Underminers Union, you can invent a new fake identity for the purpose. You know it makes sense, Comrade. Say hello to the Politburo from me, Tommy Trinder (my real name). *Wink Wink*.

    Tom

    13 Oct 12 at 8:10 pm

  33. By June 2007 Gordon Brown had unseated the Prime Minister.

    But this was pre-arranged well before this guy was hired.

    Boris

    13 Oct 12 at 8:14 pm

  34. He might as well take her down.apparently half the union/lab movement have…

    max49

    13 Oct 12 at 8:15 pm

  35. Please don’t take that anger out on the priest now Tal.

    Token

    13 Oct 12 at 8:23 pm

  36. I believe the spin meister from “The Thick of It” is based upon him.

    bolt1493

    13 Oct 12 at 8:31 pm

  37. Have posts from PJ or someone else been removed? Comments about seem to be one side of a conversation.

    Token

    13 Oct 12 at 8:40 pm

  38. Rand Paul attack ad on Dems over foreign aid:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hvnba-2sbds

    Nice work, Rand.

    Fleeced

    13 Oct 12 at 8:42 pm

  39. Hammyracist, our resident white supremacist leninist scumbag, burbles so!

    Comrades!
    I had a comment in a different thread!
    But it took all day to be moderated!
    So few of you filthy peasants would have read it!
    I’ve decided to comment in future using my real identity, the love child of William Joseph Simmons and Marie Stopes, scourge of blacks, jews, catholics and all non-white untermench!

    However, you scum may use instead my pseudonym hammyracist the white supremacist communist jew-baiter!

    FTFY, rubberlips

    Mk50 of Brisbane

    13 Oct 12 at 8:46 pm

  40. Oops, Rand stuff was on wrong Fred… sorry

    Fleeced

    13 Oct 12 at 8:47 pm

  41. Thank Mk50. So Hammy went over the top and was more than just satire of a moronic lefty.

    Token

    13 Oct 12 at 8:53 pm

  42. Have posts from PJ or someone else been removed?

    Yes. PJ had several rather, how shall we say this, uncomplimentary comments about McTernan that have been whisked into the vortex.

    dd

    13 Oct 12 at 8:59 pm

  43. No need to waste too much time deconstructing the background of that rant from that shameless shrew. She was worse than usual because She had the painters in. That is all.

    Pickles

    13 Oct 12 at 9:01 pm

  44. Did she pay for the painters with ripped off union fees :)

    Tal

    13 Oct 12 at 9:14 pm

  45. I’m gob smacked! This site is moderated :-)

    Steve of Glasshouse

    13 Oct 12 at 9:59 pm

  46. He’s the Typhoid Mary of failed political campaigns, but the idiots who hire him despite his sterling record of disaster-accompanying-him will continue to do so for one telling reason: they’re always looking to sheet the blame home to a small-minded electorate, sexism, racism, Tony Abbott and other shadowy forces, rather than looking for factors closer to themselves (including themselves).

    His legacy of disaster is as much because of the mindset of the people who hire him as anything the man himself does (or fails to do). If you think you can win by using McTernan’s tactics, the chances are you’ve already lost sight of the real reasons you’re losing.

    perturbed

    13 Oct 12 at 10:06 pm

  47. McTiernan is a lowlife of the lowest order. He didn’t just matephorically clean the dunnies at Sussex St, he recycled the crap off the bowls and threw the stuff with his own bare hands at anyone in range, with collateral damage being his hirees. My dad complained in the 70s about marxists employed out here to cause problems, but McTiernan is the putrid cream of the crop. Which gutter precisely did Gillard dredge him up from? He’s worse than anything i’ve ever had on my shoe, and unworthy to be described with such reverence. He will go down as the darkest figure in Australian political history.

    I wonder what sort of skeletons reside in his closet? Karma is required, and i find it impossible for him to be anything but putrid to the core.

    Twodogs

    13 Oct 12 at 10:16 pm

  48. Oops, Rand stuff was on wrong Fred… sorry

    This whole thread is one big case of “WTF”?

    And I state this bluntly under my new real identitah:

    Rabbi Raoul Muntovich

    Remember it, people – after the next election I am in your various thingies – whether you like it or not…

    Rabz

    13 Oct 12 at 10:25 pm

  49. Had no idea about his sexual orientation.

    But it is pertinent in light of the Abbott attacks.

    Surely you can’t get much more anti-woman than a male homosexual?

    Homosexual – I guess that’s what we’re talking about, right?

    ar

    13 Oct 12 at 10:29 pm

  50. The hypocrites are back-peddling furiously after another week of their disastrous stuff-ups which saw a campaign of lies against Abbott backfire on them. Again.

    http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/national/nobody-wins-gender-wars-wong/story-fndo48ca-1226494955849

    LABOR appears to have eased back on the so-called ‘gender wars’, with Finance Minister Penny Wong declaring no one wants that type of conflict.

    Gab

    13 Oct 12 at 10:30 pm

  51. Gareth’s PhD focussed on eastern German conceptions of personhood, through the optic of microbusiness entrepreneurship.

    Please tell me you are joking Hammygar? Please…

    Lazlo

    13 Oct 12 at 10:32 pm

  52. Penny Wong declaring no one wants that type oof conflict.

    HAHAHAHA!

    Wong claimed three nights ago on national TV that Abbott has said that women are not fit for high office!

    An emotional and intellectual vacuum..

    Lazlo

    13 Oct 12 at 10:35 pm

  53. Yes, hurried backdown in order to blunt any attack on their hypocrisy.

    PS BTW

    Rabbi Raoul Muntovich

    is a powerful name. yes it is. It commands respect.

    entropy

    13 Oct 12 at 11:10 pm

  54. With reference to Jim Murphy this is from John himself in an article (http://labour-uncut.co.uk/2010/10/18/the-tories-are-handing-defence-to-jim-murphy-says-john-mcternan/#more-4928)

    “The first rule of spin club is that there’s no such thing as spin club. The second rule of spin club is that there’s no such thing as spin. Why? Because
    the members of spin club, if such a thing existed (which it doesn’t), know that spin never stays spun. It always unravels.”

    Let’s see how he handles the “spin” regarding the AWU & Gillard as it all unravels!

    …see the latest (http://www.michaelsmithnews.com/).

    EJ

    13 Oct 12 at 11:49 pm

  55. Surely you can’t get much more anti-woman than a male homosexual?

    Nauseating, ignorant bullshit.

    perturbed

    14 Oct 12 at 2:25 am

  56. I am not sure whether McTernan just doesn’t understand Australia, or has a rather insidious brief.

    The ALP went backwards in the polls after the misogyny speech, something any advisor who knew Australia should have been able to predict: feminist issues are unpopular, even amongst women, in this country.

    Assuming he is not that stupid, the brief must not be so much the result of the next election, but to ensure Gillard keeps hold of prime ministership until then – the speech was designed to appeal to the Greens and elements within the ALP.

    2dogs

    14 Oct 12 at 3:51 am

  57. JOHN MCTERNAN: “David Cameron has a women problem”

    http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/johnmcternan1/100109638/labours-reshuffle-gives-david-cameron-even-more-of-a-woman-problem/

    Now where have I heard that before…

    Also in answer to the question about whether he works for the Government or the ALP:

    http://www.michaelsmithnews.com/2012/10/never-a-truer-word-spoken-so-let-labor-pay-for-him-or-sack-him.html

    Jock

    14 Oct 12 at 5:25 am

  58. INTERVIEWER: “Was the Prisoner Transfer Agreement some sort of grubby deal for oil?”

    JOHN MCTERNAN: “No. The Prisoner Transfer Agreement was a deal, but it was a deal to recognise the fact that Gaddafi had given up his nuclear weapons. If the price for Libya giving up nuclear weapons was that Megrahi served his sentence and died in a Libyan jail, the British Government would have been happy with that.”

    The link to the youtube video is at:

    http://www.michaelsmithnews.com/2012/10/mcternan-defends-the-indefensible-especially-as-a-scot.html

    http://www.michaelsmithnews.com/2012/10/i-need-some-sage-and-sedate-advice-should-this-be-promoted-in-the-name-of-the-australian-prime-minis.html

    Jock

    14 Oct 12 at 5:27 am

  59. “The ALP went backwards in the polls after the misogyny speech”

    I have been waiting for a post “dollies out of the pram” poll.
    Can yo point me at a poll taken since?

    Leigh Lowe

    14 Oct 12 at 5:54 am

  60. There’s nae place for immigrunt wukkers who come to Straya and tek the jabs of wukkin Strayans.
    Aye … Thets yoo McTernan

    Wee Dougie Camron

    14 Oct 12 at 5:58 am

  61. There’s nae place for immigrunt wukkers who come to Straya and tek the jabs of wukkin Strayans.
    Aye … Thets yoo McTernan

    Wee Dougie Camron

    14 Oct 12 at 5:58 am

  62. The three words that the coalition has never uttered and yet the ALP just can’t stop saying them!

    jules

    14 Oct 12 at 6:50 am

  63. No Tal, the bill goes straight to the AWU. Same as the bill for the aluminum windows and the fence. The tradies know where the money is coming from .

    Pickles

    14 Oct 12 at 6:50 am

  64. Leigh, Your query prompted me to look up the fact that: Essential Research appears to publish a weekly political poll, Newspoll is fortnightly, due next week (around 23/10/12) and Nielsen/Fairfax appears to be monthly around the middle of the month.

    However, what’s clear is that, because we have a government that can’t stop destroying itself — and wonders why — opinion polling has become the centre of the political universe and all of McTernan’s work is designed to manipulate the polls.

    His pathological talking points of just a month ago now seem so yesterday:

    In a speech to the Queensland ALP conference, Ms Gillard continued the government’s linking of Mr Abbott to Queensland Premier Campbell Newman.

    ”Newman’s budget razor is Abbott’s curtain-raiser,” she said. ”You are the sentries who can tell Australians what’s at risk, what could be coming.”

    Treasurer Wayne Swan told the conference that Mr Newman and Mr Abbott had both been ”talking the place down, running down the economy, threatening investment”.

    Ms Gillard said that at next year’s election Australians would have a clear choice. ”Do you want a high-wage, high-skill, high-value-add society where everyone gets a chance? Or a race to the bottom, cutting wages, cutting conditions, everyone going backwards, the weakest scrambling for $2 a day?

    I expect to see this week’s Essential poll putting Labor’s primary vote in a nosedive with people fleeing the PM’s shit rain of abuse to the Coalition, the Greens and “others”.

    Tom

    14 Oct 12 at 7:08 am

  65. Leigh, Your query prompted me to look up the fact that: Essential Research appears to publish a weekly political poll, Newspoll is fortnightly, due next week (around 23/10/12) and Nielsen/Fairfax appears to be monthly around the middle of the month. (Sorry, the Cat ate my links, so I had to delete them.)

    However, what’s clear is that, because we have a government that can’t stop destroying itself — and wonders why — opinion polling has become the centre of the political universe and all of McTernan’s work is designed to manipulate the polls.

    His pathological talking points of just a month ago now seem so yesterday:

    In a speech to the Queensland ALP conference, Ms Gillard continued the government’s linking of Mr Abbott to Queensland Premier Campbell Newman.

    ”Newman’s budget razor is Abbott’s curtain-raiser,” she said. ”You are the sentries who can tell Australians what’s at risk, what could be coming.”

    Treasurer Wayne Swan told the conference that Mr Newman and Mr Abbott had both been ”talking the place down, running down the economy, threatening investment”.

    Ms Gillard said that at next year’s election Australians would have a clear choice. ”Do you want a high-wage, high-skill, high-value-add society where everyone gets a chance? Or a race to the bottom, cutting wages, cutting conditions, everyone going backwards, the weakest scrambling for $2 a day?

    I expect to see this week’s Essential poll putting Labor’s primary vote in a nosedive with people fleeing the PM’s shit rain of abuse to the Coalition, the Greens and “others”.

    Tom

    14 Oct 12 at 7:11 am

  66. It’s just sad – instead of seeing the Real Julia, all we’re seeing is a sock puppet with McTernan’s hand up it’s backside. Gillard’s “angry face” is just another in a long line of pre-packaged products.

    boy on a bike

    14 Oct 12 at 7:11 am

  67. Woops. Links now approved.

    Tom

    14 Oct 12 at 7:12 am

  68. INTERVIEWER: “Was the Prisoner Transfer Agreement some sort of grubby deal for oil?”

    JOHN MCTERNAN: “No. The Prisoner Transfer Agreement was a deal, but it was a deal to recognise the fact that Gaddafi had given up his nuclear weapons.

    I actually agree with him on this.
    Gaffafi’s Libya had been slowly walked back in from the cold, which is why it was such a bad idea for the West to stab him in the back at the first opportunity.

    dd

    14 Oct 12 at 7:24 am

  69. What’s unpopular in this country is the most powerful person in the country whining about how hard they have it.

    wreckage

    14 Oct 12 at 7:30 am

  70. Yes, indeed. The most powerful politician, the one calling the shots, standing up and complaining about their hurt feelings.

    dd

    14 Oct 12 at 7:35 am

  71. John McTernan “The language of priorities is the religion of Socialism”

    Stop being surprised people.

    From Bolta http://blogs.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/andrewbolt/index.php/dailytelegraph/comments/great_skills_from_mcternan_again/

    Tapdog

    14 Oct 12 at 7:37 am

  72. So McTernan snowed Australian journalists into thinking her speech was wildly popular. Clever.
    Mind you, most of the professional commentators in Australia seem to be easily led. I get the impression that many of them get a lot of attention from the ALP spin machine.

    dd

    14 Oct 12 at 7:42 am

  73. Gaddaffi (how many spellings of that can you come up with?) may have done a bit of walking back to save his skin, but he remained a frootloop. He should have been taken to an international court himself after the shooting of a policewoman in London and the downing of the plane over Lockerbie. He never paid for those things unless you count Reagan’s air raid as sufficient – perhaps it was in part. If nothing else it illustrated that the fait accompli is useful and there should be more of them. Iranian bigwigs should be targetted as directly until their regime goes down.
    With syphilitic Gadafy there was ultimately no level of trust, and the sons were not guaranteed to turn out any better than the Syrian Assad Junior, who despite appearing more mild than his dad, still maintained strong ties to the wrong people in Iran and Lebanon. Then there are the nuclear facility that Israle had to bomb, and the chemical/biological capabilities that are even now being discussed as being in play, not ditched.

    blogstrop

    14 Oct 12 at 7:52 am

  74. Mind you, most of the professional commentators in Australia seem to be easily led.

    That’s being kind to complicit partisan hacks who are distorting the democratic process with their duplicitous deceptive dripping of disinformation daily.

    blogstrop

    14 Oct 12 at 7:54 am

  75. It’s true that Julia Gillard as PM on a salary of near $500,000 plus perks saying life hasn’t been fair ‘cos she’s female doesn’t quite add up.

    candy

    14 Oct 12 at 8:14 am

  76. If nothing else McTernan certainly makes his incompetent predecessor,Hawker,look good.

    Lew

    14 Oct 12 at 8:42 am

  77. John McTernan was also Mike Rann’s media adviser,Mike Rann is no longer the Premier of S.A.

    Merilyn

    14 Oct 12 at 9:20 am

  78. At least Gina Rinehard wants to import workers with a track record of success. Julia imports a loser with a track record of failure.

    I find it interesting in this sense that he is gay, would he attack a Coalition leader for being gay? I have no doubt about it. McTernan is the politics of relentless negativity and personal destruction. But he is wrong in his ramblings, I mean writings about spin. Eventually the public hate personal destruction and negativity. Especially female voters, which is why the ALP pins that tag on Abbott.

    The left loves confected anger and rage, so they are naturally drawn to the vile political pugilist – McTernan. What the ALP hates about Abbott, is that he gives some back. Like all Lefty bullies they can’t take it back. Remember the mincing poodle remark about Pyne. They are not above a bit of homophobia themselves, just like the nasty undertones about Alan Jones. So the gay guy is happy to work for an organisation that deploys homphobia to score political points and silence their political opponents.

    In the end Gillard will be another notch on McTernans belt of failure. A despicable Scot peddling the most divisive and dishonest politics for the grubbiest government in this country’s political history. He must be proud of himself.

    John Comnenus

    14 Oct 12 at 9:55 am

  79. boy on a bike 14 Oct 12 at 7:11 am.
    “Gillard’s “angry face” is just another in a long line of pre-packaged products”.

    Very true, succinct. Nearly all that needs to be said.

    The Margie Abbott-led fightback to the McTernan meme (fronted by all those female puppets) had to be attacked and Slipper had to be protected at all costs no matter what he did. Albanese had the script ready BEFORE they even knew about the motion to remove Slipper. Gillard read from that script. Feigned outrage and horror (until the CFMEU joke sent it a little sour).

    “ What do you want us to say now John?”

    M Ryutin

    14 Oct 12 at 10:04 am

  80. So McTernan snowed Australian journalists into thinking her speech was wildly popular. Clever.

    BS, the Stenographers were desperate reaching for a way to spin the fact Gillard made the most colossal blunder.

    The story fails the sniff test with the rest of the community. Ultimately it reinforces the disconnect between the media insiders and the rest of us.

    Token

    14 Oct 12 at 10:10 am

  81. I think Timmee would have been very familiar with every thing that was spewed at Abbott during her 15 minute rant.It was probably just a compilation of what he’d received on any number of occasions.I wonder if he’s been game to come out of his shed yet just in case she hasn’t finished and needs him to practice on.

    Lew

    14 Oct 12 at 10:38 am

  82. ”Newman’s budget razor is Abbott’s curtain-raiser,” she said.

    That’s amusing because it’s the one thing I have my doubts on about Abbott in my support of him whether he will take out the butcher’s knife.

    JC

    14 Oct 12 at 10:45 am

  83. Heaven help Timmy if he ever looks at his watch during one of gillard’s tirades.

    Gab

    14 Oct 12 at 10:45 am

  84. So McTernan snowed Australian journalists into thinking her speech was wildly popular. Clever.

    It was a made up emotional rant. Abbott made the mistake of sitting there with a straight face. I would have laughed myself on the floor.

    JC

    14 Oct 12 at 10:48 am

  85. “The ALP went backwards in the polls after the misogyny speech”

    They saw it for what it was. They saw the Lying Slapper going into emotional overdrive at Abbott because of his silly shit stirring by calling them a Government dying of shame (he could have chosen different words). But on the same day the government was desperately attempting to keep Slipper’s speakership alive, who is Exhibit A for laying out hate against women.

    JC

    14 Oct 12 at 10:53 am

  86. so Abbott Abbott Abbott has to be blamed for juliar employing the scottish git.
    Love the post about Timmmmee staying in the shed,every woman has been there,not only the PM.
    Not many women put up with that sexist hype in a real marriage,most will let it rip on the homefront

    lorraine palmer

    14 Oct 12 at 11:01 am

  87. Wow, we are in up-side-down world, for once Mad Dog Milne’s daily rant actually is for something in alignment with middle Australia:

    GREENS Leader Christine Milne has criticised Julia Gillard’s firebrand speech attacking Tony Abbott for perceived sexism, saying it was diminished by Labor’s decision to protect Peter Slipper.

    Ms Milne suggested there were shades of hypocrisy to Ms Gillard’s passionate parliamentary attack on Mr Abbott because of the government’s defence of Mr Slipper who was found to have sent derogatory texts about female genitalia.

    Token

    14 Oct 12 at 11:12 am

  88. So Milne is now back-peddalling also from her position a few days ago:

    Greens leader Christine Milne has accused Opposition Leader Tony Abbott of being a “hyper-masculine” perpetrator of sexism in Parliament, even though she says he doesn’t realise it half the time.

    Senator Milne told The National Times that all female parliamentarians experience sexism, including Prime Minister Julia Gillard and herself: “That’s the reality.”

    She said Mr Abbott specifically was part of the problem, along with people such as shock-jocks, but that his comments were deliberate only some of the time.
    Greens leader Senator Christine Milne.

    Greens leader Senator Christine Milne. Photo: Andrew Meares

    “Half the time I don’t think he even realises it,” she said.
    Advertisement

    Senator Milne said: “He [Mr Abbott] very much epitomises the hyper-masculine style of male politician … and he trades on that.

    “His attitude to women is very much of the male dominated, male protection, the father looking after the women as very much the secondary players … and no amount of bringing his wife into the public arena is going to change people’s perception of the kinds of remarks he makes.”

    Today, Senator Milne backed Ms Gillard’s impassioned speech against Mr Abbott’s misogyny and sexism, particularly in relation to his comment about the government dying “of shame”.

    Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/political-news/abbott-guilty-of-sexism-milne-20121010-27cz5.html#ixzz29ER5Ygfx

    Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/political-news/abbott-guilty-of-sexism-milne-20121010-27cz5.html#ixzz29EQW3I9M

    Gab

    14 Oct 12 at 11:18 am

  89. GREENS Leader Christine Milne has criticised Julia Gillard’s firebrand speech attacking Tony Abbott for perceived sexism, saying it was diminished by Labor’s decision to protect Peter Slipper.

    Oh dear. What does Milne say about Bandt also voting for Slipper?

    jupes

    14 Oct 12 at 11:34 am

  90. For some realisation how concocted and shallow the whole Gillard/Albanese script about sexism was please read this article by Miranda Devine and especially check the context for the ‘abortion is the easy way out’ nonsense.

    http://blogs.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/mirandadevine/index.php/dailytelegraph/comments/gender_card_is_a_loser/

    On another ‘charge’ I have been amazed about the woeful ignorance by so many commentators about the context of the (ongoing) debates about inherit qualities of men and women from which a supposed instance of actual misogyny has been extracted to level against Abbott.
    Never having seen a link to the actual debate with Michael Costa, from the moment I heard Albanese give a preview of Gillard’s Hollywood script BEFORE the motion to remove Slipper was moved, I thought of two words: “Larry Summers”.
    If the former Obama adviser Summers’ experience whilst President of Harvard university was anything to go by, the shrill and anti-intellectual sexism shouters would have a field day IF the debate was anything like the one for which Summers suffered so much from the politically correct. When Summers wondered if women by their very nature suffered in their aptitude for certain sciences compared with men he was shouted down as sexist and his resignation demanded, no matter that he was supported by his academic peers and superiors.

    The Abbott quotes revealed so far IN NO WAY SHOW ANYTHING OTHER THAN SUCH AN INTELLECTUAL DISCUSSION. More than that, apart from the crass anti-intellectualism these responses show, the base political nature of this Hollywood preview by Gillard and her scriptwriters ignores entirely the hypocrisy of attitudes towards valid surveys and intellectual discussion where women are deemed to have certain admirable qualities which men lack or in which men are not so able to exercise (women leaders are more persuasive than their male counterparts, women leaders learn from adversity and carry on with an “I’ll show you” attitude, women leaders demonstrate an inclusive, team-building leadership style of problem solving and decision making, women leaders are more likely to ignore rules and take risks) and so on….

    M Ryutin

    14 Oct 12 at 11:36 am

  91. Oh dear. What does Milne say about Bandt also voting for Slipper?

    what does Milne say now about Slipper voting for the green levy?

    JUST last year Peter Slipper said the carbon tax would devastate the economy and threaten the big tourist attractions in his electorate.

    He said he “hated to think” of the impact on families.

    None of that seemed to matter yesterday when the former speaker ratted on his constituents and voted with the Labor government twice in support of the green levy. He voted to link Australia’s carbon price with Europe’s, the measure passing the House of Representatives 71 to 68.

    Mr Slipper, who was elected as an LNP candidate before leaving the party to become Speaker last year, then sided with the government again when he helped vote down a Coalition motion calling for the carbon tax to be scrapped.

    He told parliament last year the government should have gone to an election, saying: “It is wrong, in my view, to say one thing before an election and then change one’s mind.”

    Gab

    14 Oct 12 at 11:45 am

  92. speaking of Milne, Dennis Jensen has just posted on FB:

    “Was sitting next to Christine Milne (leader of the Greens) on a flight from Canberra to Sydney on Friday. Pilot came over PA, saying that on the left (my side of the plane) there was snow on the hills around Sydney, and was extremely unusual for this time of the year. One of the flight attendants was bending down to look out of my window to see and I said “must be because of all that global warming”. Milne didn’t look very impressed, but didn’t respond either!”

    Will

    14 Oct 12 at 1:40 pm

  93. One of the flight attendants was bending down to look out of my window to see and I said “must be because of all that global warming”.

    The unseasonal spring weather is entirely consistent with, indeed one of the features of, climate change.

    Gareth Hamilton

    14 Oct 12 at 1:49 pm

  94. Just like every other meteorological event that occurs now or in the future.

    John Mc

    14 Oct 12 at 1:52 pm

  95. The unseasonal spring weather is entirely consistent with, indeed one of the features of, climate change.

    It’s simply amazing what’s consistent with climate change: hot weather , cold, rainy, drought, more intense volcanic eruptions, the pain in my arse etc etc etc

    JamesK

    14 Oct 12 at 2:01 pm

  96. see http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/gillard-barred-for-snivelling-grub-slur/2006/05/31/1148956383658.html

    the now PM in opposition called Abbott a “snivelling grub” for tit for tat reasons.

    Jim Rose

    14 Oct 12 at 2:16 pm

  97. …indeed one of the features of, climate change.

    Yes, this is very serious climate change is the one that is due to the change in tilt in the access of the earth based upon an annual cycle.

    Its called the year.

    Token

    14 Oct 12 at 2:30 pm

  98. What does milne say about bandit also voting for the musselman?

    How do you know a greenie shithead is lying?

    Their lips are moving.

    Rabz

    14 Oct 12 at 2:40 pm

  99. Gareth Hamilton, if you have anything at all between your ears, perhaps you could tell me about this.

    Tell my why the CO2 keeps rising, yet the temperature doesn’t.

    Will

    14 Oct 12 at 3:02 pm

  100. Any chance we can resist the urge to turn this thread into another blisteringly dull climate thread?

    Gab

    14 Oct 12 at 3:06 pm

  101. Any chance we can resist the urge to turn this thread into another blisteringly dull climate thread?

    Dull climate thread?

    There are fewer and fewer exciting climate threads now thanks to climate change.

    Our children will probably never experience an exciting climate thread

    JamesK

    14 Oct 12 at 3:25 pm

  102. Gareth Hamilton, if you have anything at all between your ears, perhaps you could tell me about this.

    Doesn’t mean a thing. 16 years is not even a blip in climate history. Climate changes in spurts and pauses from time to time. I’d rather believe in the scientific forecasts of true scientists rather than politically-driven denialists.

    Gareth Hamilton

    14 Oct 12 at 4:27 pm

  103. Communists just love those politically-driven scientists! Have you even heard a “climate scientist” dissociate himself from the Greens?

    Tom

    14 Oct 12 at 5:13 pm

  104. Apologies for interrupting another climate change thread, but I wanted to correct a common misapprehension about John McTernan. He is not a spin doctor. He is far superior to mere spin doctors, being actually a rotation physician. He is FRCRP (Fellow of the Royal College of Rotation Physicians). He is highly skilled in the repellent arts and practices of his ilk. The Canberra press gallery could be played like a fiddle by virtually anyone on the left, but in this guy’s thrall, they make Pravda look objective.

    James in Melbourne

    15 Oct 12 at 11:33 am

  105. [...] A few days ago I said that Gillard’s spin merchant was going to ensure her loss at the next election (or sooner if Rudd returns), like McTernan had to his previous employers. [...]

  106. [...] I noted before on John McTernan’s genius for undermining his boss and ultimately causing his/her removal. His latest stratagem - having Julia Gillard announce an election for 14 September and to encourage the resignation of three Labor Ministers – takes the cake. Labor figures must be jumping with joy at the prospect of defeating Tony Abbott with this masterstroke. I wonder who McTernan’s next client will be? Perhaps Swannie will take him on? [...]

Leave a Reply