New Agenda

The ANU has a very nice policy orientated journal Agenda edited by William Coleman. The latest issue is out with a focus on health economics. It includes a paper by our very own Henry Ergas and two by Alex Robson (lurker and sometime threadster) and Eric Crampton of Offsetting Behaviour fame. Eric sets the tone

A good health economist is a bit like a platypus, or at least so-says a health economist colleague of mine.2 The friendly beast must combine a clinician’s medical knowledge with an economist’s techniques, both theoretical and empirical, and a bureaucrat’s understanding of the administrative structures within which policy operates. Perhaps the health economist’s empirical techniques are not as refined as the theoretical econometrician’s, just as the platypus’s fur is perhaps not quite as soft as that of a kitten, but it does a good job of combining a set of characteristics that are normally not found in one place. Unfortunately, health policy instead seems set by a chimera that rather seems to have taken the design specifications for the platypus and decided that the kitten should in fact provide the beak and the duck provide the fur: we too often find combined the clinician’s goal of health care, as maximand; the economics undergraduate’s captivation by partial equilibrium and neglect of general equilibrium; and the bureaucrat’s inadequate respect for methodological individualism. The papers in this Agenda Special Issue on health economics work to bring more standard economic method back into health policy analysis.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to New Agenda

  1. Yes that looks a very good issue – but it’s a shame it came out just before the ghastly CCC Report on Climate Change and Health by Leslie Hughes and Tony McMichael released today, as that really needs taking apart, and who better to do that than Ergas and Robson?

    It is serially dishonest propaganda. I give just one example, its claims that increases in number of days p.a. with temperatures above 35oC will increase across all Australia’s capital cities as early as 2030 leading to massive increases in mortality.

    In reality some of the world’s fastest growing cities have always had very many more days above 35oC than even Darwin, e.g. Khartoum, Dubai, etc etc. So far from dying like flies their populations are always increasing exponentially.

  2. Another absurdity in the CCC’s report (Hughes and McMichael) is their claim that there is a one-to-one relationship between outdoor temperature and body temperature!

  3. Rafe

    A factoid for youg Cats, the first editor of Agenda was Michael James who moved from CIS Policy to Agenda. Can’t remember when. Too long ago:)

Comments are closed.